Car Rentals in Fire Island, USA

The price of a rental car per day on Fire Island often depends on how far you book in advance and what car class you choose. Use our ‘Filter by’ section to see any special offers and to view the cost per car class for vehicles on Fire Island.

Depending on your hire policy, you may qualify for your money back. Many rentals offer a total refund if you notify us a minimum of six hours prior to picking up the car. Need more info? If you can’t find the answer in your itinerary, our Customer Service Portal is available 24/7.

If you’ll be visiting some of the more populated areas on the island, it’s best to think small — like an economy-sized car. The most booked hire type on Fire Island, they can easily get around the streets, squeeze into narrow parking spaces and offer fantastic mileage. But there’s nothing stopping you from going big either! Check out our standard or full-size options if you want some extra space, or take things up a notch with one of our sleek premium rides.

Fire Island and its surrounds are brimming with things to see and experience, and there’s no easier way to explore them than with a rental car. Kick off your itinerary with these well-known attractions:

• Feel the wind in your hair, the water splashing your feet and the salt in the air at Robert Moses Beach. Stick around for sunset to cap off a memorable day out.
• Fire Island Lighthouse was designed to help guide vessels through dangerous waters. Still a distinguished local landmark today, it’s bound to have a few stories to tell about sailing triumphs and tragedies.
• A prominent structure that’s withstood the test of time, don’t miss Robert Moses Water Tower. It’s a popular attraction for history fans and regular tourists alike.

Expedia is the place to go to book a car. With multiple suppliers on Fire Island to select from, we always work hard to get you awesome deals. Score savings with our exclusive offers and member prices, and earn rewards every time you book. You’ll save even more when you bundle your bookings into a Fire Island holiday package. Car rentals, hotels, flights, activities — Expedia has everything you need in one handy place.

Browse our extensive range of car rentals, check out reviews and compare offers from big-name brands. In a few easy clicks, Expedia will help you find the best deal on your ride. Got a flight or hotel booking? Add on your Fire Island car hire to save even more money.

Drivers have to be at least 21 years old to hire a car on Fire Island. Renters under 25 are usually charged additional fees, as statistics show younger drivers are more likely to be involved in accidents. Check the fine print before you lock in a car to avoid any unpleasant surprises at the hire counter.

The main requirements are a driver’s license and a credit card. Ensure that both are in the driver’s name. Got more than one motorist in your group? They should also be there at the time of pick-up and provide the same documents. Don’t forget to check your policy agreement for details about any auto insurance you may need as well.

Look for bargains by using the ‘Filter by’ feature when choosing your rental car for Fire Island. For the most affordable car hire, we recommend booking well in advance. Be aware that certain car categories may incur higher costs.

Yes, you can rent a vehicle for a month or more. Just enter your dates and pick-up and drop-off locations, and we’ll search for the most competitive long-term car rental deals around. Don’t speed through Fire Island — cruise the ocean roads at your own pace!

Age policies will likely differ between Fire Island rental providers, so you’ll need to check before you book if you’re under 25. Also, see if a young driver’s fee applies. Having a solid understanding of the terms and conditions will help avoid any misunderstandings and hold-ups at the hire counter.